• Home
  • Our Books
  • Our Film
  • Games
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Login

Perspectives on all eras of videogames, computers, technology, and pop culture since 2003

Login

Login
Armchair ArcadeArmchair Arcade
Armchair ArcadeArmchair Arcade
  • Home
  • Our Books
  • Our Film
  • Games
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Login

The myth of the graphics-centric gamer

The myth of the graphics-centric gamer
The myth of the graphics-centric gamer

The myth of the graphics-centric gamer

September 25, 2020 Posted by Bill Loguidice Editorial 1 Comment

The “gamer who is only fixated on graphics” theme is a popular one, but one that I don’t feel is based in reality. There have been plenty of cases of games over the decades with then state-of-the-art graphics getting critically savaged or selling poorly because the gameplay wasn’t there to match. Flashy audio-visuals might get you noticed and might get someone “in the door” so to speak to try your game, but it’s obviously not an indicator for success. Even using a classic example of a game like Dragon’s Lair, which remains undeniably beautiful for obvious reasons, still has an argument to be made for its gameplay, such as it is. While there are plenty of other examples of games where you could argue it was flash over substance (Defender of the Crown, Shadow of the Beast, Battle Arena Toshinden, etc.), only in very few cases, say with a game like Rise of the Robots, could a pretty solid case be made that there are/were no other redeeming factors than its visuals (and the developers of Rise of the Robots learned that the hard way when people had already caught on by the time Rise of the Robots 2 came out – word DOES spread).

And then you only have to look at some of the most popular games today, like Minecraft, Fortnite, Rocket League, Dwarf Fortress, Grand Theft Auto V, Hearthstone, Civilization VI, etc., to see that gameplay still rules even if the visuals are not necessarily best-in-class. And when games like Flight Simulator 2020 do set new visual standards, there’s often considerable depth underneath (or, similarly, enhanced visuals actually enhance the gameplay with things like improved draw distances, more in-game objects, etc.).

Even though it's getting a graphical overhaul soon, Dwarf Fortress gained its fame looking like this.
Even though it’s getting a graphical overhaul soon, Dwarf Fortress gained its fame looking like this.

So no, I don’t think we’ve ever REALLY had a flash over substance issue in gaming. It’s just one of those tropes that gets repeated, particularly as an argument for when a game’s visuals are subpar or not aesthetically pleasing, that gameplay should rule. And of course, everyone agrees that gameplay should rule and it certainly CAN trump weak visuals, but at the same time, considering what even the most modest technology is able to display these days, subpar visuals or subpar aesthetics are hard to excuse. It’s the classic, “Why not both?”, which is arguably truer today than ever.

Why not both? And really, you're ultimately there to play a game, not play the graphics.
Why not both? And really, you’re ultimately there to play a game, not play the graphics, so why would the graphics be prioritized as a player anyway?

Related

Tags: audio-visualsdragon's lairdwarf fortressflight simulatorfortnitegraphicsmemememesMinecraftmythmythologyrise of the robotsstereotypes
1 Comment
Share

About Bill Loguidice

Bill Loguidice is a Founder and Managing Director for Armchair Arcade, as well as a critically acclaimed technology author and journalist.  He is also the co-founder of creative services firm, Armchair Creative Services, and a noted videogame and computer historian and subject matter expert. See full bio

You also might be interested in

The Influence of Social Media to the Gaming World
The Influence of Social Media to the Gaming World

The Influence of Social Media to the Gaming World

Nov 25, 2018

Similar to other industries, the gaming world has experienced several[...]

New book, Fortnite For Dummies, is now available!
New book, Fortnite For Dummies, is now available!

New book, Fortnite For Dummies, is now available!

Jul 11, 2019

My newest book, Fortnite For Dummies, is now available. In the book, I cover all you need to know about the most popular free-to-play Battle Royale game of all-time. It's available from wherever books are sold, including Amazon, where you can get it in a value-priced paperback or Kindle edition.

Get a Free For Dummies Book Just for Sharing!
Get a Free For Dummies Book Just for Sharing!

Get a Free For Dummies Book Just for Sharing!

Jun 25, 2019

Wiley is kicking off a cool new contest where you can get a FREE Dummies book, like mine—Fortnite For Dummies! All you have to do is share a video on Facebook or Instagram detailing how a specific Dummies book has changed your life. That’s all! Then you get to pick any Dummies book for free! At this time, only submissions from the US are being accepted.

1 Comment

Leave your reply.
  • Siegfried Lenz
    · Reply

    October 20, 2020 at 9:09 AM

    While the ideal might be that graphics quality becomes an entirely artistic choice, I suppose that for the foreseeable future graphics quality will very much remain a function of budget as creating good looking 4K 3D graphics simply needs more manpower/money/talent than creating retro(-styled) pixel graphics.

Leave a CommentCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts

  • The Bilestoad (Apple II) versus Crusader (MSX) cover art – It’s a mystery!
  • How Blockchain Is Changing The Way We Watch And Play Sports
  • Casino classic bonus codes 2025
  • AMPOMOV Wireless Lavalier Microphone – Quick Video Review
  • GameSir Unveils X5s Wireless Mobile Game Controller with Tri-Mode Connectivity
  • Why are credit card casinos seeing a new resurgence at online casinos?
  • PB Tails Three-Body Problem Droplet Edition Chromeposite Mirror Controller Unboxing Video!
  • Sweepstakes Gaming Software: A Practical Guide For Sportsbook And Casino Operators
  • Free-to-Play Slots and the Return of Risk-Free Gaming Culture
  • Game Library Depth and Provider Diversity at Versailles Casino Focus on What Aussie Players Want

Recent Comments

  • The Evolution of Slot Machines in Casinos – STARGAME on Understanding Online Sportsbooks: Key Features Gamblers Must Know for an Enhanced Experience
  • Sharon Hill on Never before seen Hulk Hogan and Andre the Giant WWF photos from 1981!
  • leads dubai on Should You Be Focusing More On Local Marketing?
  • Aiodensghost on Official Game List for My Arcade Atari Gamestation Pro
  • keyboredom on Quick guide on how to play on the Internet Arcade
  • Bill Loguidice on Official Game List for My Arcade Atari Gamestation Pro
  • Melanie Levenstein on Official Game List for My Arcade Atari Gamestation Pro
  • George on How to Predict CS:GO/CS2 Skins Prices?
  • Bill Loguidice on Retro Games Ltd to release The Spectrum, fully working ZX Spectrum, and here’s the game list!
  • Derek on Retro Games Ltd to release The Spectrum, fully working ZX Spectrum, and here’s the game list!

Archives

Categories

Explore

android (46) apple (37) ar (39) Arcade (170) Atari (76) atgames (173) book (99) books (98) casino (563) esports (48) firmware (43) Flashback (45) gambling (587) Gaming (41) home arcade (115) htc vive (42) humble bundle (282) humble store (67) ios (37) led (35) legends (40) legends arcade family (46) legends pinball (39) legends ultimate (71) Microsoft (40) Nintendo (72) PC (33) pc gamer (67) pc gaming (53) pinball (43) playstation (55) PS4 (36) retro (34) Sega (38) slots (92) sony (51) steam (145) switch (34) technology (36) update (42) virtual pinball (36) virtual reality (117) vive (34) viveport (42) vr (123)

Affiliates

+ Amazon

The everything store

+ ACEMAGIC

Amazing PC, mini PC, and laptop deals

+ Humble Bundle

Game deals, including name your price bundles

+ Playasia (Play-Asia.com)

Import games and collectibles

+ DJI Store

Amazing drones and related technology

+ Razer

Amazing PC gamer products!

fullSTEAMahead365 Your total news and information resource for all things Science, Technology, Engineering / Mathematics, Art, and Medicine / Health.

Human Advancement Never Stops.

Key Site Statistics

Posts published: 2,675
Latest publish date: August 27, 2025 @ 10:55 am
Registered user count: 99,026

Contact Us

If you have a question, would like to provide feedback, or otherwise wish to get in touch with us, use this form.

Send Message

Blog Posts by Date

September 2020
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930  
« Aug   Oct »

Social Media and RSS

Support Armchair Arcade

All editorial content © 2003 - 2025 Armchair Arcade, Inc., an Armchair Creative Services, LLC, property. All rights reserved unless otherwise indicated. All trademarks and copyrights are retained by their respective owners. No content is to be removed or reused from the Armchair Arcade Website for commercial purposes without explicit permission from the principal Armchair Arcade staff, or the original trademark or copyright holders. Armchair Arcade, Inc., is not responsible for the content of any external sources or links. Further, endorsement of any external sources or links is neither implied nor suggested.

We thank you for your support and encourage you to contact us for any reason, including, but not limited to, questions, concerns, business endeavors, or praise. Especially praise.

Armchair Creative Services, LLC, may earn compensation for sales from links on posts through affiliate and other programs. Editorial rigor and objectivity standards are strictly adhered to and any compensation has no effect on coverage or opinions.

Prev Next