• Home
  • Our Books
  • Our Film
  • Games
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Login

Perspectives on all eras of videogames, computers, technology, and pop culture since 2003

Login

Login
Armchair ArcadeArmchair Arcade
Armchair ArcadeArmchair Arcade
  • Home
  • Our Books
  • Our Film
  • Games
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Login

Editorial: Will a great videogame always be a great videogame?

Ultima IV Remastered (C-64)
Ultima IV Remastered (C-64)

Editorial: Will a great videogame always be a great videogame?

June 22, 2017 Posted by Bill Loguidice Editorial No Comments

There’s a belief out there that “good games are always good games.” You might even call it a mantra. While this may sound surprising coming from someone like me, I don’t necessarily agree.

Sometimes what was great in the past “ages out” when we get used to a better, different, or simply other way of doing things. I think it’s usually easier for action-style games to stay relevant and playable, but harder for games like RPGs. At least that’s been my experience, particularly in recent times.

A counter to this idea is that they wonder if maybe the game wasn’t that good in the first place if it’s not good today. I don’t agree with the “wonder” premise. Some things are just of their time, period. If they were great in and of their time, but are not enjoyable anymore, I don’t think that diminishes their greatness. That’s more an argument of timelessness vs greatness. Some things, like action games, are by their nature, more conducive to being timeless.

This is not a strictly videogame phenomena either. The same thing applies, for instance, to a lot of the movies we’d watch multiple times as kids. Tastes change and evolve, and media of their time don’t always come with us. I know a few years back when I watched the original Star Wars trilogy with my kids – something I watched myself countless times around their ages and loved – it was a bit hard to get through. Those were amazing films in their time, but pacing and special effects have really changed in the 30 years since they were released. Acknowledging that doesn’t make those films any less than they were, though. That’s kind of like saying Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar was never a great game because it’s so difficult to get into today. In the context of its time, it was amazing and was for a long, long time after its release. Not everything has a “forever” shelf life.

In response to that I’ve heard the argument about why should a game or movie be compared to the time it was made rather than stand alone for what it is? Certainly a particular media creation can stand alone and be judged for what it is, but then that goes back to the earlier argument about if something doesn’t hold up, maybe it was never great in the first place. Again, I don’t agree with that. I’m suggesting that we need to acknowledge that sometimes greatness has a shelf life or needs to be considered in the context of its time.

Going back to the Ultima IV example, I think we can unequivocally acknowledge its greatness, importance, influence, etc., while acknowledging that it’s going to be a heck of a lot harder to enjoy it today. Even going back to my action game argument, let’s take something like the Atari 2600’s Pitfall!. That’s a timeless game to be sure, but is it really as much fun today as it was back in the early 1980s? Probably not. We’ve changed and certainly today’s gamers (and those of us who have been around forever) have different expectations. That doesn’t – or at least shouldn’t – diminish its greatness. Of course, like our ongoing series on casino technology here at Armchair Arcade, e.g., the best online casino games, some experiences probably are timeless regardless, but it helps when they’re given a fresh new look and feel to cater to modern tastes.

Related

Tags: actionArcadeclassiccrpgrpgvintage
No Comments
Share

About Bill Loguidice

Bill Loguidice is a Founder and Managing Director for Armchair Arcade, as well as a critically acclaimed technology author and journalist.  He is also the co-founder of creative services firm, Armchair Creative Services, and a noted videogame and computer historian and subject matter expert. See full bio

You also might be interested in

PAPRIUM

PAPRIUM, an amazing new beat ’em up for the Sega Genesis/Mega Drive released!

Mar 28, 2017

WaterMelon Games, creators of the excellent Pier Solar and the[...]

Gameplay video of Cactus Jack's (Gottlieb) on the AtGames Legends Pinball (011)
Gameplay video of Cactus Jack's (Gottlieb) on the AtGames Legends Pinball (011)

Gameplay video of Cactus Jack’s (Gottlieb) on the AtGames Legends Pinball (011)

Apr 20, 2021

This is the eleventh (011) in a series of quick[...]

Video: What you want to know about the Toy Shock Taiyo 12-in-1 three quarter scale home pinball machine with Haunted House, Black Hole, and more
Video: What you want to know about the Toy Shock Taiyo 12-in-1 three quarter scale home pinball machine with Haunted House, Black Hole, and more

Video: What you want to know about the Toy Shock Taiyo 12-in-1 three quarter scale home pinball machine with Haunted House, Black Hole, and more

Dec 10, 2019

I already did a first impressions write-up with photos and[...]

Leave a CommentCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts

  • How Cybersecurity Frameworks Like NIST 800-171 Protect Your Data
  • How To Find the Right Printing Partner for Your Nonprofit
  • Data Center Switch Basics: A Simple Guide For Beginners
  • Power Of Data: How LinkedIn Scraping Can Transform Your Research
  • Evercade Alpha TAITO Bartop Arcade coming, more NeoGeo and other cartridges, plus updated game list!
  • What to know about compliance when you play at social casino online sites
  • What are bonus buy slots?
  • 4 Things To Do While Visiting Los Angeles
  • Modern Gaming Monitors: What to Look for When Choosing for Esports Disciplines
  • How to Keep Your Competitive Edge in Online Games

Recent Comments

  • Aiodensghost on Official Game List for My Arcade Atari Gamestation Pro
  • keyboredom on Quick guide on how to play on the Internet Arcade
  • Bill Loguidice on Official Game List for My Arcade Atari Gamestation Pro
  • Melanie Levenstein on Official Game List for My Arcade Atari Gamestation Pro
  • George on How to Predict CS:GO/CS2 Skins Prices?
  • Bill Loguidice on Retro Games Ltd to release The Spectrum, fully working ZX Spectrum, and here’s the game list!
  • Derek on Retro Games Ltd to release The Spectrum, fully working ZX Spectrum, and here’s the game list!
  • Bill Loguidice on Retro Games Ltd to release The Spectrum, fully working ZX Spectrum, and here’s the game list!
  • Simon on Retro Games Ltd to release The Spectrum, fully working ZX Spectrum, and here’s the game list!
  • Viktor Špička on Retro Games Ltd to release The Spectrum, fully working ZX Spectrum, and here’s the game list!

Archives

Categories

Explore

android (46) apple (37) ar (37) Arcade (167) Atari (74) atgames (173) book (99) books (98) casino (501) esports (47) firmware (43) Flashback (45) gambling (525) Gaming (40) home arcade (115) htc vive (42) humble bundle (282) humble store (67) ios (37) led (35) legends (40) legends arcade family (46) legends gamer (33) legends pinball (39) legends ultimate (71) Microsoft (40) Nintendo (70) pc gamer (67) pc gaming (53) pinball (43) playstation (55) PS4 (36) retro (34) Sega (38) slots (83) sony (51) steam (145) switch (34) technology (35) update (42) virtual pinball (36) virtual reality (116) vive (34) viveport (42) vr (121)

Affiliates

+ Amazon

The everything store

+ Humble Bundle

Game deals, including name your price bundles

+ Playasia (Play-Asia.com)

Import games and collectibles

+ DJI Store

Amazing drones and related technology

+ Razer

Amazing PC gamer products!

fullSTEAMahead365 Your total news and information resource for all things Science, Technology, Engineering / Mathematics, Art, and Medicine / Health.

Human Advancement Never Stops.

Key Site Statistics

Posts published: 2,551
Latest publish date: May 31, 2025 @ 3:46 pm
Registered user count: 99,026

Contact Us

If you have a question, would like to provide feedback, or otherwise wish to get in touch with us, use this form.

Send Message

Blog Posts by Date

June 2017
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« May   Jul »

Social Media and RSS

Support Armchair Arcade

All editorial content © 2003 - 2025 Armchair Arcade, Inc., an Armchair Creative Services, LLC, property. All rights reserved unless otherwise indicated. All trademarks and copyrights are retained by their respective owners. No content is to be removed or reused from the Armchair Arcade Website for commercial purposes without explicit permission from the principal Armchair Arcade staff, or the original trademark or copyright holders. Armchair Arcade, Inc., is not responsible for the content of any external sources or links. Further, endorsement of any external sources or links is neither implied nor suggested.

We thank you for your support and encourage you to contact us for any reason, including, but not limited to, questions, concerns, business endeavors, or praise. Especially praise.

Armchair Creative Services, LLC, may earn compensation for sales from links on posts through affiliate and other programs. Editorial rigor and objectivity standards are strictly adhered to and any compensation has no effect on coverage or opinions.

Prev Next